Ep.36 · Case file

In Boston’s record winter of 2015, ice dams became up to half of one insurer’s new claims.

In the winter of 2015 Boston had the snowiest season in its records. By mid-February the city had taken a record six feet of snow in a 30-day period, beating the previous 58.5-inch mark set in 1978, and February itself averaged 19.0°F (−7.2°C), the city’s second-coldest month on record. The insurance industry saw what came next before most homeowners did. Arbella’s vice president of claims said February 2015 was on track for well more than double the claim volume of February 2014, and that ice dam claims "easily represent 40 to 50 percent of the new claim volume." One local agency that usually saw two or three claims a week reported 30-plus claims in a single week, and warned that the worst ice dam damage could cost tens of thousands of dollars. Later that year Mapfre, the state’s largest commercial home insurer, asked regulators for a first-of-its-kind ice-dam deductible of up to $10,000 for homeowners with repeated ice-dam claims; in December 2015 the Massachusetts Division of Insurance rejected it.

An ice dam is a ridge of ice along the lower edge of a roof that holds back meltwater. Joseph Lstiburek of Building Science Corporation states the conditions in one line: ice dams happen when the outside temperature is below freezing, the roof deck is above freezing, and there is snow on the roof. The warm deck melts the bottom of the snow. The water runs down under the snow to the overhang, which sits outside the heated house and is much colder, and freezes there. The ice builds up, the next meltwater backs up behind it, and it finds its way under the shingles and into the ceilings and walls below.

The question is where the heat in the roof deck comes from when it is −7°C outside. In most houses the answer is the house itself. Leaky penetrations in the ceiling, around light fittings, hatches, pipes and wiring, and heating ductwork run through the attic let warm room air rise straight into it. That air collects under the roof, highest at the ridge, and warms the deck from below. This is why two houses on the same street, with the same snow, can look so different: the one with the heaviest ice along its eaves is usually the one losing the most heat into its attic. Small icicles from snow melted by the sun are normal and, as Lstiburek notes, do not back water up; a dam is a different thing. It is also why the common responses do not solve it. Heating cables melt channels through the ice with more energy, and a waterproof membrane under the whole roof limits the damage, but neither stops the dam from forming.

The established fix is the vented roof Lstiburek describes: an airtight ceiling, deep insulation on top of it, and outside air washing the whole underside of the roof deck from the soffits to the ridge to carry away whatever heat still gets through. He notes that ventilation only works to remove small amounts of heat, so you need a lot of it, and recommends a 2-inch minimum airspace under the sheathing in heavy-snow regions, where most codes call for only 1 inch.

Zephyr’s simulation of a simple gabled house shows both states with −7°C outside. With five typical ceiling leaks, warm air rises through the attic, runs up the underside of the roof and collects along the ridge; the roof deck under the snow sits at about +3°C, the snow melts, and meltwater freezes into a dam and icicles on the cold overhang. In the second run the ceiling is sealed and outside air enters at the soffits, flows up in a thin layer under the deck and leaves at the ridge. The deck under the snow settles at about −6°C, below freezing, and the snow stays snow. These are the simulation’s numbers for a model house, not measurements of any building in Boston.

The same reasoning applies to any cold-climate roof over a heated space: the ice at the edge is a measure of the heat leaving through the ceiling, and both the leak paths and the roof airway can be checked before the snow arrives.

Sources

Does your building do this?

Tell us the building and we’ll show you where the air goes.